I would take issue with you first/second choice point, in my opinion it's similar to saying a prop that is deemed more effective off the bench is second choice and therefore inferior.



The fact is Wire play with 2 hookers and Higham is one of them. There will be a lot of people (inlcuding me) who would say he should have played a lot more minutes this year as Wire have more often thatn not looked a better and more dangerous team with him on the field.



He had a bad time at Wigam, but you could say at least a small pasrt of that is the shambles your club was in for some of that time, and using him wrongly.



As for your quastion as to whether Saints would go for Higham if Roby was out - I blummin well hope we would as he'd be brilliant cover; I think Higham might just have edged a game ahead of Stuart Howarth . . . . .

My recollection is that Higham was replaced by Mark Riddell, who was a totally different type of player. He was bought to bring some control to the play, and was very much a similar style to MMc, not flashy, got the job done, a very good passer of the ball.



The players reckoned he was the toughest in the group, but he was useless in his first season, until Madge got hold of him, made him lose weight and he started to prosper.



Higham was ok at Wigan but Brian Noble didn't fancy him, thought he was a headless chicken. He spent his whole time at Wigan trying to get Terry Newton back. It was Millward's brainwave to get rid.



Higham's done well at Wire. But he only plays half a game at most. Defo better than most though. I'd put Roby, Lunt, Clark, Hodgson, Houghton, MMc, Monas & Henderson ahead of him (not in that order necessarily)

I think that last post emphasis a difference in philosophy. Between Wigan and Saints.

It also demonstrates why Millward did not work at Wigan. He tried to take the Saints style to Wigan and it probably was undoing years of inbreding there (sorry training).



Noble was a much better fit for Wigan. Same for Riddell and MM, in a Saints outfit they would be seen as very unproductive players. In the Wigan outfit they buy into that style of play. I would not quite call it a juggernaught style of play like Bradford used to be, but it is a more defensive style, counter attacking if you like. Pin them down and hope for the mistake. Strangely that is what we will be relying on come Saturday due to the nature of our team at the moment lacking creative players.



The funny thing is, in my head I know we can't win but the closer the game gets the more I start to convince myself we can.. Strange how the head can be over ruled at times. Nothing has changed, yet the simple passage of time raises hope.



I thought we had good odds despite losing Walsh of finishing top. I think I gave us a 60% chance of winning the LLS and I would have settled for that as I thought it would give us a good bash at getting to a final if not winning one.



But now it's here, you just have to hope don't you.

I think its only fair to comment that the Mick Higham of the last couple of years is a much better all round hooker than the "One Trick Mick" that we shipped to Wigan who themselves shipped on.

Last year especially he really impressed me with his craft around the ruck.

To be fair Monas was used off the bench because of injury problems starting to take their toll and Clarke because he was starting to run out of steam after the Challenge cup. Neither was, or is, a bench hooker and I [uguarantee[/u Clarke will start for Wire next season. I also think you're giving too much credit to the 2 hooker system. In ALL cases throughout the league you start with your strongest players. There are no examples that I can think of where this is not the case unless there are injury or fitness issues.



Ditto regarding prop FTV. There are indeed instances where a player is more effective from the bench. In all but the rarest of instances, they are 'impact' players, younger players or players physically unable to do long minutes. That is exactly where Higham fits in. He is an impact hooker good at speeding the ruck up, particularly when defences are tiring. I too would be happy if you'd replace Roby with Higham. Please do it on Saturday in fact!

C champions





you walked right into that mate lol

Your a couple of days late in posting mate. Its all ready been allocated C = Cannonball

W = what a mind numbingly boring thread.

Grand Final Derby week - as expected really. In fact, I'm surprised it's been as quiet as it has.

I see the tenants are being bossed around again - if they win on Saturday they can't play the wcc on the Sunday as scheduled as Dave whelan's favourites are at home.



So we're left with the prospect of no longer having two games building up to the big one, but the winners sandwiched between the meaningless games.



So glad we have our own home.

bossed about by a championship team, now thats embarrassing