Eh?



Whiting had the ball whilst standing on the line, therefore in touch...

That only stands when the ball is caught on the full.



For me the only wrong call he made was the 'taken out in the air' that lead to the 2 points. And even that split the commentary team, a little off thread topic but is anyone else impressed with Jon Wells' examinations?

Silverwood is a crafty bleeder and says Mirfield which is pretty much Huddersfield but has always been able to ref Huddersfield games.



It worked before and I don't know why the scrapped it, so what if Bentham can't ref Warrington, I'd be ecstatic if he couldn't ref Cas games.

That decision was correct.

However...

Whiting did not ground the ball over his own line...a try followed the drop-out.

The double knock-on near Saints line should have gone to Hull feed.

The equalising penalty was an incorrec decision no matter what Eddie and Stevo said.



Another ref may have given these decisions but justice should be seen to be done by a neutral ref.

Whiting was in touch when he caught the ball. Therefore the kick found touch and play should have continued as if the ball had hit the touch line itself (with a Hull scrum).

Isn't that only if it is taken on the full?

I thought Ganson had a good game today. The penalty for the kick was a 50-50 in slow-mo, real time it would be difficult not to give it.







I like him. He a little bit differnet, but good analysis, and doesnt seem to everyone off like Phil Clarke.

I'm pretty sure he did, albeit unintentionally

Then why did they create that silly rule about players making the ball dead by sticking a foot over their dead ball line? Fullbacks started defusing kicks that were bouncing in the in-goal area by stepping over the dead ball line and then touching the ball. This (prior to the silly rule) resulted in a tap on the twenty as the ball was judged to have gone dead in goal without being touched. Same principle applies to in-touch.

It wasn't a double knock on. It never left Fosters hand until the saints player knocked it forward from foster's grasp.

The ball hit Horne and then whiped his hand away so was not a knock-on also why twice Hull players off side from kicks but not Foster at the other end when exactly same happened?

Oh and don't you just love Gansons run across O'Melley then [ i've got to stand somewhere answer.

Even a player knows you don't move across a tackler thats obstruction.