I certainly agree with the Butcher. Nothing against Tomkins, works hard. We seem to assembled a steady eddie, high work rate team. Feel we will be just treading water this next season. Interesting that a lot of the players are on one year contracts, giving Salford the scope to improve on signings for 2017 season

Very odd signing this, given that when speaking to Sheens at the end of last season he said himself Tomkins wouldn't be retained and that he had big plans for Hood. I suppose Hood wanting to move over to Australia scuppered those plans and we've had to get someone in as #2 hooker.



The fact he has only signed a one-year-deal suggests Tomkins is just a stop gap, until something better comes along for 2017.

I agree with the "treading water" comment and is this squad of "steady mediocurs" going to cut the mustard.

Hopefully they gel but I feel for the worst in the middle 8s Bradford will be knocking again and Leigh have recruited heavily.

I realise from first hand experience over the past two years this doesn't always work, but they will be an extremely difficult team to beat in the 8s. Especially with players out to prove a point.

Better than nothing I suppose.

Well it's another in the long line of Salford signing the "Other brother"



Nothing against Tomkins but I hate to say it but that Yorkshire fools words (Danny Lockwood) keep on ringing in my ears "Salford will keep Wakefield off the foot of the table"



Very underwhelmed.....

i've been very underwhelmed by the signings this season and unless things change its gonna be bottom 4 the championship, sadly.(:

Sorry who is our director of rugby again? I'll trust the outgoing Australian coach before any of you negative lovers!!!!

Let him do his job and assemble a team with the type of players he sees fit and stop bloody moaning and dissecting every signing we make!!!

If we are a pile of cack next year then you can moan then ffs, but not a week into pre season training!!!

Good grief what a bunch of glass half empty folk!



Can I remind you of the last two years? We signed big names on expensive contracts, had an England/GB coach running the show and got precisely where? NOWHERE!!!



I'm with NorthMancDevil and I'll trust Tim Sheen's judgement before anyone on here



FFS lighten up and let's look forward to next season

Put it this way we've done our shopping at Netto this year, lets see if Tim can polish .

[url=http://www.nhs.uk/conditions/seasonal-affective-disorder/Pages/Introduction.aspxsymptoms are more apparent and tend to be more severe during the close season.[/url



All gone a bit John Laurie around here ,



if Logan is ' slow 'be thankful we didn't re-sign Stuart Howarth, tectonic plates & glaciers could out-pace him.



Of the players announced so far I wouldn't say Netto, I think more TS Maxx with Vidot , Carney, Lui, Murdoch Masila, Kopczak.

Of the signings Phil Joseph is the only that I find questionable.

Quite agree middleman, some people are over exaggerating when it comes to rating our signings. Tomkins whilst no world beater, is still a good player. As you say, Carney, Vidot, Lui, Kopczak and Murdoch-Masila are all very good signings.

I've listed our squad, and rated them accordingly to other super league club players. On paper its worrying in my opinion. Our recruitment hasn't improved the outgoings. I doubt any of our players would get in any other Superleague team apart from Evalds, Vidot, and Carney.Kopczac borderline



1. Evalds proven quality IMPROVING talent

2. Vidot Proven quality BJB outgoing ( IMPROVEMENT )

3. Griffin - Borderline superleague quality ( STAGNANT )

4. Sau - Borderline superleague quality ( STAGNANT )

5. Carney Proven quality Replaces Johnson ( IMPROVEMENT )

6. O'Brien- Something to prove Chase outgoing ( DECLINE )

7. Dobson Bottom 4 quality ( STAGNANT )

8. Kopzac- Average Morley outgoing ( STAGNANT )

9.-Lee Tomkins- Lee Average, Tomkins - Borderline superleague quality ( STAGNANT )

10. BMM - Something to prove not played much NRL last year.Taylor outgoing (DECLINE)

11. Hauraki - Average (STAGNANT )

12. - Flanagan Average Paterson outgoing ( DECLINE )

13. - Krasniqi - Championship player Hansen outgoing ( DECLINE )

14. - Lui - queensland cup player something to prove

15. - Joseph Championship quality Tasi outgoing (DECLINE )

16. - Walnut Brothers - Championship quality ( STAGNANT )

17. - Forster - Championship quality ( STAGNANT)

18.- MCB - Something to prove Borderline superleague quality ( STAGNANT )

19. - Johnson Average ( STAGNANT )

20. Haggerty - something to prove unknown Matua outgoing ( DECLINE )

21. - Griffin Borderline superleague player ( STAGNANT