Wouldn't have got injured if he wasn't cheating by holding George Carmont back and if he wouldn't have held him back I reckon we would have scored whether it have been George all the way or if he passed it back to Pat.



On another note I wish him all the best and hope he recovers, it is a loss for England as he has been in good form but I wish he would cut out the cheating and concentrate on playing rugby.

Random, but you can have that one if you like.



Don't get me wrong - I'm not happy about it; when I said it's tough for him, I meant it. Not sure how to summon up any more sympathy for the lad though when he chucked himself into a reckless, illegal tackle and ended up injured.



Genuinely, I hope he makes a full and speedy recovery.

Sad news, hope he's at full fitness asap, but you live by the sword, you die by the sword.

Hard luck that really it is.

McGuire's all speed, this operation to sort it will not go down well for him.

If he didn't pull Carmont back, it would never of happened..

kirkamania6 couldnt have said it better myself it was his decision to hang on to him and out stretch hisself and put his knee under pressure

Could not put this any better. im rather gutted hes injured as i hope we go to Leeds next week, but there is 1% of me thinking acutlly he deliberately cheated caused their coach to make an allegation againt our player. Sorry he got what was coming. For a player like Peacock i really feel sorry for him but Maguire resorted to cheating and paid a massive price for it.

I don't think any person with half a brain would really wish an 8-month stint out of action on him. In the heat of the moment last night I probably wasn't the only one who hoped his leg had actually fallen off but, being realistic, being out for just a week or two to teach him a lesson would suffice. 8 months must be heartbreaking.

He injured himself committing an illegal tackle off the ball. I do have sympathy but nothing else to be said.

I've watched it a few times and it looks like it went before he grabbed at carmont

Hope it was worth it danny.