My take it on it
Probably a Red - Probably a 2 game ban
Do I think it was "Really Bad"? - Not really
Reason? I Don't think he intentionally went to smash him with the Forearm/Elbow etc as his arms are next to his Body Not leading with them, I think he just went to shoulder charge him to dislodge ball and he got it wrong at 100mph.
Maguire tried the same thing on Fielden and got it right, Ablett got it wrong.
PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE!
Can we stop the over reactions by both sides when it comes to instances like this!
Wigan fans accept that if one of our players did it we would be looking for every piece of reasoning to justify why it wasn't as Bad as everyones making out (See Andy Coley send off Thread) whilst Leeds fans please see that your doing just that!
On the other Hand Wigan fans don't make it out to be More than it was, If he'd have gone leading with the Elbow/Forearm the yes I would say it was a "Horrible" or "Disgusting" tackle. IMHO I think it was More reckless and over zealous.
It was certainly no "Cassidy" tackle that's for sure!
PS
Same goes for the Joel Tomkins thing the Other day against Wire, Player dove in slightly late (Bearing in mind there was an unusaual delay with Myler not grounding the Ball straight away) and Tomkins went in IMO in an uncontrolled manner.
Right decision, Yes, If he'd got 1 game, I wouldn't have argued.
It's a rough/tough game - I sometimes wonder what some people would make of the game of yesteryear 70's/80's, They'd have had a Firing squad out at the Disciplinary for some of the stuff that used to go on!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/bbfa5/bbfa5fc2059ec2d9f2e4b15ea06c1f7fd6936a17" alt="Wink icon_wink.gif"