Nailed on I would say

Not exactly clear on what players have to do to get a nomination, but does nobody else think that Carmont would be in with a good chance?



If its voted by players I wouldnt be shocked to see him get votes, very modest and classy player and seems a genuine bloke.



I see Tomkins and Westwood etc as all worthy winners but I wouldnt mind seeing Carmont there, think he has had a great year mixing his good all round consistancy with some really good flashes (see the other thread for examples).



Saying that i may be completely off the mark.

Every player has a vote. 3 points, 2 points and 1 point.



When all votes have been counted the top 3 become the shortlist for the awards night, every rugby player that has put theirs on Twitter (around 10-15) have all picked Tomkins as top and i have spoken to a few Saints players who all went Tomkins/Westwood/Manu

Ryan Baily.

Will be hodgson Or Westwood for me and Agar for coach. Regardless of bulls in a mess money wise theg had a good squad.

Cant see how Agar will get coach of the year.



He led a team into 8th position!?



Hows that for rewarding mediocrity.

For consistency Roby or Westwood, for ability Tomkins.

Gotta be Roby. Would like Carmont or Tomkins to get it but it has to be Roby for me.

Roby??



Oh come on. Have they renamed this the "One Trick Pony of the year award"?



Roby is a good player, but if running from dummy half was outlawed, this guy would have to retire.

Unfortunately that sentiment ticks a rather large box at RFL HQ.

Not wrong.

We have played Stains 4 times this year and MM bullied him the first 3 times and in the last game we all know what happened, for me Roby still didn't shine. Having said that he played well against Wire in the playoff, but he was not the matchwinner that the sky commentary team make out, it was actually Soliola.



Tomkins MOS by a country mile.