MOS. Roby? Chase? What a load of shiite.

MOS is a popularity show and has so little importance in my opinion, I judge a players on how they perform and the silverware they win.

Lost all credability for me when Barrett didnt win it

Sadly, you're right. The Barrett debacle proved that a panel of 'RL experts' can't be trusted. The fact that some clown actually voted for Danny Maguire as MOM at Wembley last year shows the RL press can't be trusted. And last year's Man of Steel showed the players can't be trusted.



There's basically no-one left, so the whole thing is a farce.

I would like to see the coaches have a vote. They watch the games more than anyone.

I think the coaches would be the best judges. They watch the players the most and make plans to stop other teams danger men so will really be focussing on that particular seasons best players. I think the majority are sensible enough to vote fairly on the issue as well.



It could be no worse then the journo's or players voting for it going off past results.

TBH The player's player is the best way to go about it. Just because you don't agree with the result, doesn't mean they can't be 'trusted'.



If a panel of his peers vote Chase MoS, then he is MoS, you can't complain just because you feel Sam was the better player, that's your opinion, in the Player's opinion Chase was better. I have no problem with that.

The argument some people are making though is that some players will have voted for Rangi Chase not because they thought he was better than Sam Tomkins, but because they simply don't like Sam Tomkins & wouldn't want to see him win it.

Spot on. Nobody can actually claim that Chase is a better player than Sam.

You would have thought the whole of Leeds would have boycotted voting for Tomkins and a few other clubs with bitter players would have done the same purely based on jealousy and the fact he's embarrassed many of them on the field. MOS appears to be a personality contest amongst the players who have stood out the most during the season.

Do you have any proof of this? To say they didn't vote for him because they don't like him is a wild accusation to make without any proof.

Who had a bigger impact on Super League 2011, Sam Tomkins or Rangi Chase?



If your answer is Sam Tomkins you must concede the only reason other player's didn't vote for him is because they don't like him.