Eddie wasn't a buffoon. They just kept him in the role too long and he got old.
He was a game changer when he started.
You've got to remember in Eddie's days there was no support with side kick or producers. He did it all on his own.


Ray French though took it up a level as a very intelligent guy who could talk well about the modern game that was changing fast.
He was a real breath of fresh air at the time.


Duel International as a player too.


RIP Ray.

He was very knowledgeable of the game, no doubt about that, but sorry PT, Uncle Eddie WAS a buffoon. I remember  one game at Headingley him following a white paper bag blowing across the pitch believing it was the ball.

incredibly uncharitable! 


By the end of his commentary career Waring was suffering from early signs of dementia and within two years of his retirement was committed to full time care in a nursing facility. 


By comparison in his earlier career he was a very successful journalist and team manager, and was personally responsible for the lobbying of television companies to take Rugby League as an an early adopted sport for the BBC. 


By the end, I too, felt the sport needed a new voice, but calling a man who did so much for our sport, and was ultimately affected by a terrible disease, a buffoon? 


I met French very briefly a couple of times whilst I was involved with Derby City RL ... A gentleman indeed, with a passion for the game akin to his predecessor,,, 

First of all Spooki may I suggest that you look up the definition of the word buffoon, ie "Jester, fool".
I probably remember Eddie prior to your memories of the man during the fifties and sixties  long before his latter day health problems.and, believe me, he alienated a lot of rugby league fans by some of the comments that he came out with on national television. There was no comparison between Eddie Waring and his successor Ray French 

Let's not take this in another direction. 
This is a Ray French thread.

Redscat: First of all Spooki may I suggest that you look up the definition of the word buffoon, ie "Jester, fool". I probably remember Eddie prior to your memories of the man during the fifties and sixties  long before his latter day health problems. and, believe me, he alienated a lot of rugby league fans by some of the comments that he came out with on national television. There was no comparison between Eddie Waring and his successor Ray French  sorry poptart but when someone questions my intellect i cannot walk away i am a child of the 60s and my recall has a personal connection to the latter days of Waring's life. I was asked to do something so I did. And will leave it there: buffoon noun buf·​foon 1 : a ludicrous figure : clown 2 : a gross and usually ill-educated or stupid person acting like a ridiculous buffoon

Redscat: First of all Spooki may I suggest that you look up the definition of the word buffoon, ie "Jester, fool". I probably remember Eddie prior to your memories of the man during the fifties and sixties  long before his latter day health problems. and, believe me, he alienated a lot of rugby league fans by some of the comments that he came out with on national television. There was no comparison between Eddie Waring and his successor Ray French  sorry poptart but when someone questions my intellect i cannot walk away i am a child of the 60s and my recall has a personal connection to the latter days of Waring's life. I was asked to do something so I did. And will leave it there: buffoon noun buf·​foon 1 : a ludicrous figure : clown 2 : a gross and usually ill-educated or stupid person acting like a ridiculous buffoon