Really? Out of interest what u seen in whiting this yr? Been p poor in most his games!!

Careless post maybe? (Sorry)

Bit harsh on Hadley. I'm not a Whiting basher but his form has been poor most of the season, maybe injuries who knows, certainly hasn't lived up to his "superman" tag. Could be his testimonial year, playing with his head but he may have to move on shortly? My wife will be devasted though.

For real? What you on?

Whiting unfortunately has had the testimonial curse,He has not had the best season by far,its not knocking the guy its the truth even he knows that. Yeaman has not been that bad ,like the rest of the outside backs he has hardly seen the ball.If Crooks was interested I would give him a place next week but rumour has it he has spit his dummy out. Months ago I said HTW should have had a go but now Sneyd is on his way his chances unless injuries strike he is unlikely to get a run next season. Sa should have played instead of Whiting last week with Thompson on the bench both can play centre or in the pack.A win next week would be good but wont IMO be a disaster if we lose,the season has been poor and nothing will change that

Hadley isn't as good as some make him out to be, and I think Turgut will become the better player of the two. But on this seasons form, I'd play Hadley ahead of Whiting who's had a poor season by his own standards.

wheres bowden ? agree about hadley derserves his place although i still have doubts about his size, saying that the kids always runs hard,

I agree that Whiting has been poor,Testimonialitis strikes again but even a out of form Whiting offers much more than Hadley who just seems to be a plodder of a 2nd rower...he may come good but at this time,I don't see what he offers.

On a opinions forum and my opinion is Hadley is no better than what we have and won't get a look in next season with Minichello arriving unless Ellis is bumped upto prop but then maybe Turget will emerge

İmo I think hadley is our second most consistent second rower behind Ellis. He runs varied lines not just straight and predictable. Away at catalans him leaving the field injured cost us two points. What's with the Turget love on here anyway? Surely would be playing if playing that well?

I said he may emerge....he is line breaking 2nd rower with speed but isn't ready yeat for SL.He may run varied lines but doesn't look like breaking them.

Need to be very wary of Turgut, bit of a muppet off field.